Door:
Annita Kirwa

21 July 2026

Tags

Creating jobs for young people has become a global development priority. But are we asking the right questions? At the Challenge Fund for Youth Employment’s first Café Dialogue in The Hague, policymakers, investors, businesses and development practitioners challenged long-held assumptions about what it really takes to turn investment into sustainable employment.

The Dutch summer is often a season of reflection, dialogue and connection. In The Hague, an international centre for dialogue and collaboration, public spaces provide a serene setting for meaningful conversations. Seizing this opportunity, the Challenge Fund for Youth Employment (CFYE) hosted its first Café Dialogue in The Hague on 9 July 2026.

The dialogue, themed ‘When Does Investment Become Employment?’, marked the beginning of a series of conversations. It brought together diverse perspectives on how governments, businesses, investors and development organisations can create more jobs for young people. The discussions centred on a critical question in international development: How do we create sustainable jobs for young people at scale?

This question builds on nearly seven years of experience, learning and reflection. It reflects an ongoing effort to understand what truly works and which assumptions should be reconsidered in the pursuit of sustainable employment opportunities for young people, both today and in the future.

Since its establishment, CFYE has achieved several milestones, including launching more than six challenge calls and developing a diverse portfolio of over 130 partners working to address youth unemployment.

Over the years, the fund has generated significant experience and insights through its partnerships with private-sector organisations across Africa and the Middle East. While CFYE can take pride in its contributions to advancing youth employment, the dialogue reflected a sense of humility and a shared recognition that there is still much to learn.

Opening the afternoon session, moderator Ms Nour Serry emphasised that the purpose of the Café Dialogue series was not to position CFYE as the definitive expert on youth employment. Rather, it was to create a space for collective reflection and knowledge exchange.

As Ms Serry noted, despite CFYE’s experience in the field, ‘We can never claim to be the sole experts on such a complex challenge.’ Rather than seeking consensus, the Café Dialogue aims to stimulate discussion and identify practical lessons for future employment policy and investment.

What assumptions are we making about youth employment?

To start the conversation, Ms Nimrah Karim, Senior Manager, Technical Assistance, Strategy, and Impact at CFYE, delivered a keynote address reflecting on key lessons from the fund’s journey. At the core of the keynote was a reflection on four widely held assumptions common in youth employment programming across the development sector.

Importantly, these assumptions were not presented as theoretical propositions but as reflections tested against six years of implementation experience and evidence gathered through the Pathways to Employment (PTE) learning series. The objective was not to determine whether the assumptions were universally true or false, but to examine where CFYE’s evidence supported, challenged, or added nuance to them.

keynote by Nimrah Karim (CFYE) ©Olivia Decker

The first assumption was, ‘Training creates jobs.’ Drawing on evidence from the PTE learning series, Ms Karim suggested that this is an incomplete assumption. Training only yields meaningful outcomes if there is a structured pathway to employment.

This can only be achieved if employers are involved from the outset and curricula are aligned and co-created to reflect market realities. The transition to work must also be actively supported, often through commercially viable mechanisms such as internships and apprenticeships.

The second assumption was, ‘Inclusive models must be scaled.’ Ms Karim argued that this is not always the case. High-impact models do not always have the ability to scale sustainably.

Scale tends to occur when several factors align. These include a strong product-market fit, sound unit economics, operational agility, the ability to pivot when needed, and diversified revenue sources. Equally important is integrating inclusion into core business operations rather than treating it as a donor-driven add-on.

The third assumption was, ‘Donors know what businesses need.’ Ms Karim suggested that reality is more nuanced. Businesses are often best placed to determine what is commercially viable, and development actors should avoid assuming they know better than the market.

For example, it may be unsustainable to hire a large workforce simply to meet a donor requirement. Every decision has to make commercial sense. Focusing excessively on donor targets can undervalue broader impact and limit a company’s agility to pivot strategically or operationally when market realities change.

The fourth assumption was, ‘Supporting individual businesses is enough to create employment.’ Ms Karim challenged this assumption, suggesting that employment outcomes often depend on wider systems and value chains, not just on individual firms. For example, agribusinesses are often better able to predict their workforce needs when they maintain greater control over the wider supply chain.

It is important to consider how the entire value chain functions, extending beyond production to include processing, distribution, off-taking, market inputs and advisory services. Having visibility across the supply chain not only improves business viability but also helps address seasonality risks.

The assumptions themselves are not new to donors, implementers and development practitioners working on youth employment and related issues. However, what resonated with participants was that Ms Karim’s assessment was grounded in CFYE’s evidence-based experience and practical learning from the organisation’s portfolio of projects.

These included digital marketing skills training in Nigeria, last-mile e-commerce distribution in Senegal, clean energy distribution in Uganda, and an initiative to strengthen the dairy value chain in Kenya. She challenged participants to consider how these four assumptions play out in practice and whether they reflected the experiences of implementers, funders, donors and private-sector actors.

How well do the assumptions align with lived realities?

The four assumptions underpinning youth employment programming formed the basis of the panel discussion. The panel comprised Olivia Douwes, Senior Policy Officer at the Department of Sustainable Economic Development at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs; Rahel Boon-Dejene, Founder and CEO of the R&D Group of Companies; and Martijn Blom, Impact Fund Development Coordinator at Impact Europe.

The panellists related closely to the assumptions, drawing on their own professional experience. Reflecting on the assumption that supporting individual businesses is enough to create employment, Rahel Boon-Dejene shared her work promoting decent jobs through business outsourcing services. She argued that supporting a single organisation alone is unlikely to generate employment at the scale required. Instead, she suggested taking a broader ecosystem approach.

On the assumption that donors know what businesses need, Olivia Douwes offered a different perspective. In her view, donors operate within a very different landscape, while the private sector is increasingly becoming part of the donor ecosystem. Donors, including the Netherlands, engage not only with other donors but also with implementing organisations. Ms Douwes emphasised the importance of managing expectations from the outset and being clear about what works and what does not.

Regarding the assumption that inclusive models must be scaled, Martijn Blom presented another perspective. From the viewpoint of an impact investor, Mr Blom argued that sustaining quality jobs is just as important as scaling them, particularly for marginalised communities. Rather than focusing solely on growth, he suggested placing equal emphasis on long-term social impact. As he noted, the growth of a company does not necessarily translate into the growth of employment opportunities.

Guiding the discussion, Ms Nour Serry asked the panellists to reflect on how they would respond if funding from either an impact investor or a donor came with impact objectives that could potentially undermine a business model. Despite representing different sectors and perspectives, the panellists converged on a common view: such situations should be addressed through co-creation and alignment of incentives.

From left to right: Nour Serry (CFYE), Olivia Douwes (MFA), Rahel Boon-Dejene (R&D Group) and Martijn Blom (Impact Europe) ©Olivia Decker

Are job targets alone sufficient as a measure of success?

For a long time, the success of employment programmes such as CFYE has been measured primarily by the number of jobs created, without taking into account other indicators of indirect impact. This emphasis has been shaped by the targets set by donors, investors, social enterprises and other development actors. For example, CFYE has set an ambitious target of creating decent employment opportunities for 230,000 young people by the end of 2026.

However, perspectives on what constitutes success are evolving. Reflecting on this shift, Olivia Douwes, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs’ focal point for CFYE, noted that target setting is inherently influenced by the political priorities prevailing when programmes are designed. As development priorities change, so too should the metrics used to assess progress. Rather than focusing solely on the number of jobs created, there is growing recognition that employment programmes should also consider the quality, sustainability and broader developmental impacts of those jobs. This includes whether jobs provide decent working conditions, contribute to social inclusion, and generate positive economic and environmental outcomes. According to Ms Douwes, donors have an important role to play in driving this transition.

Key performance indicators (KPIs) are often designed by donors. Several speakers suggested that implementers, who understand local realities, should play a greater role in defining success through these KPIs. Donors, in turn, could encourage innovation by issuing more open-ended calls for proposals, allowing implementers to propose context-specific KPIs. While indicators such as job quality are undoubtedly more difficult to measure, the panel agreed that complexity should not be a reason to avoid measuring outcomes that genuinely reflect sustainable development.

The time required to achieve development targets was also identified as an important consideration. Ambitious development goals require sufficient time for implementation. The original ten-year programme timeline reflected the political and funding environment in which CFYE was established. Today, development cooperation faces the challenge of shrinking Official Development Assistance (ODA) budgets, posing significant challenges to sustaining long-term development initiatives. However, participants agreed that this should not become an excuse for lowering ambition.

What is missing or overlooked in the pursuit of youth employment?

Discussions around job creation often revolve around training, skills and opportunities for youth economic empowerment. Yet, while a significant share of development funding is channelled into skills training, these programmes are too often disconnected from labour market demand.

A participant representing Plan International asked, ‘What happened to the discussion on the enabling environment?’ This prompted two critical questions: Is the enabling environment the missing ingredient for job creation? And are we overlooking both the formal and informal realities of the labour market?

Another topic of discussion was how donor-driven training models can create unintended incentives. In Ethiopia, for instance, training has become an industry in itself, giving rise to ‘training hoppers.’ These are individuals who move from one donor-funded course to another because participation is rewarded rather than because it leads to employment.

Participants called for a fundamental shift from supply-driven to demand-driven skills development. Instead of asking how many people have been trained, more important questions are: What skills do employers need? Where are the jobs of the future? And are training programmes equipping people for those opportunities?

Without stronger links between training providers, employers and labour market needs, investments in skills are unlikely to translate into decent, sustainable employment.

©Olivia Decker

Key policy recommendations

Participants joined interactive table discussions, where they explored the four assumptions, reframed as questions, in greater depth and developed recommendations for policymakers, investors and development practitioners. The following key insights and recommendations emerged during the closing plenary.

Are we investing too much in training and not enough in employers?

The group recommended rethinking how skills development programmes are designed. Rather than offering broad, generic training, programmes should prioritise specialised, demand-driven training that equips individuals with skills sought by employers and directly enhances employability.

Training should also deliver tangible value to businesses by improving productivity, efficiency and competitiveness. Where possible, programmes should support firms in obtaining recognised certifications that can unlock new markets, strengthen business growth, and ultimately create more and better jobs.

They  the importance of communicating evidence to policymakers. At the same time, participants cautioned that training serves multiple purposes. Therefore, the fact that it does not directly result in employment does not diminish its value.

©Olivia Decker

Can social enterprises create jobs at the scale we need?

The group challenged the assumption that all social enterprises should scale. Instead, participants argued that their primary value lies in their ability to innovate, experiment, and address social challenges in ways that conventional businesses often cannot.

Rather than prioritising scale from the outset, they recommended creating spaces for dialogue where social enterprises can pilot and refine innovative solutions, particularly in niche and emerging markets. Such spaces would allow promising ideas to be tested, evaluated and adapted before decisions about scaling are made.

Participants also highlighted the need to strengthen collaboration between social enterprises and the private sector. By fostering dialogue and partnerships, social enterprises can improve their commercial viability while preserving their social mission, ultimately positioning themselves to achieve greater and more sustainable impact.

©Olivia Decker

Are donors asking businesses to do things that make little commercial sense?

The group noted that creating meaningful social impact is inherently resource-intensive and requires realistic expectations from both donors and businesses. Too often, the two operate with different priorities, incentives, and ways of measuring success.

To bridge this gap, participants recommended creating structured opportunities for dialogue between the private sector and donor organisations. Grounded in practical examples and shared learning, these conversations would help develop co-created, context-sensitive key performance indicators that are both ambitious and feasible.

©Olivia Decker

What matters most for job creation: supporting individual businesses or strengthening entire markets?

The group called for greater investment in the enabling environment as the foundation for sustainable job creation and inclusive economic development. Participants also identified trade corridors as emerging areas of opportunity that could create new employment prospects for young people and therefore deserve greater policy and investment attention.

The discussion emphasised that social impact should remain at the centre of development interventions rather than focusing solely on commercial returns. This requires measuring not only immediate outputs, but also systemic change and long-term transformation, supported by longer investment horizons that allow meaningful change to take root.

Finally, the group stressed the importance of locally led partnerships and co-creation. Working closely with local organisations and, critically, with young people themselves ensures that programmes are grounded in local realities, address genuine challenges, and are better positioned to achieve lasting, scalable impact.

©Olivia Decker

Key takeaways

The discussion concluded with a reminder that progress requires collective action. No single actor, whether a donor, implementer, investor, business or government, can deliver sustainable development alone.

Addressing complex development challenges requires shared responsibility. Rather than assigning blame or expecting one actor to lead, stakeholders must work together to combine resources, expertise and perspectives.

While the scale of the challenges remains daunting and progress may seem incremental, moderator Nour Serry closed the discussion on a note of cautious optimism. Her concluding remarks highlighted that recognising the gaps, fostering dialogue, and taking small but deliberate steps towards more collaborative and adaptive approaches are meaningful achievements in themselves. Sustainable development is a long-term endeavour, and lasting change will depend on the willingness of all actors to continue learning, partnering and working towards shared goals.

Nour Serry (CFYE) ©Olivia Decker

What next?

The event concluded with an invitation to continue the conversation at the Challenge Fund for Youth Employment’s final programme event, to be held on 17 November 2026 in Amsterdam. It is framed as both a celebration of the programme’s achievements and its conclusion, while also providing an opportunity for broader dialogue across the youth employment ecosystem. It will reflect on the lessons learned and explore how they can inform future policy and practice in the private development sector.

Participants were encouraged to continue engaging in the conversation as the programme transitions from implementation to knowledge sharing and helping shape the next generation of youth employment initiatives.

 

 

 

 

COP31 moet veel meer gaan over huidige slachtoffers van de klimaatcrisis

By Sabina Voogd | 12 November 2026

Leuk dat we met z’n allen steeds meer elektrische auto’s kopen, maar daar bevriezen de gesmolten gletsjers in de Himalya niet opnieuw van. Sabina Voogd van WaterAid Nederland pleit daarom voor een verdeling van het klimaatbudget dat recht doet aan hen die nú al getroffen worden door de klimaatcrisis. 

Lees artikel

Particuliere initiatieven in beweging voor een eerlijkere wereld

By Yvonne van Driel | 06 November 2026

Hoe kunnen particuliere initiatieven bijdragen aan een eerlijkere wereld? En hoe krijgen we nog meer mensen in beweging? Tijdens de Partindag op 31 oktober in Nijkerk stonden betrokkenheid, samenwerking en de kracht van vrijwilligers centraal. Een dag vol persoonlijke verhalen, inspirerende workshops en nieuwe ontmoetingen.

Lees artikel

Less thunder, more lightning: a message to the Dutch governement

By Moses Isooba | 05 November 2026

Who really benefits from the new generation of international partnerships? Moses Isooba, Executive Director of the Uganda National NGO Forum, welcomes the Dutch AIV’s ambitious vision but questions the growing emphasis on Mutually Beneficial Partnerships and joint investments. What benefits governments and businesses may leave communities empty-handed. His warning: country ownership is not the same as community ownership

Lees artikel